The business judgment rule protects honest mistakes, not ignored red flags. Recent claims show where the line falls. In this article we look at the background, the key issues and what readers should do next.
The background
To understand why this matters now, it helps to look at how the position developed. For years the rules in this area were settled, and most practitioners could advise clients with confidence. That changed as courts, regulators and clients began asking harder questions, and as new technology and business models exposed gaps that the old approach never anticipated.
The result is a period of uncertainty. Different courts have reached different conclusions on similar facts, guidance has been issued piecemeal, and the practical burden has fallen on the people and businesses who have to make decisions before the law is fully settled. For readers, the most important point is that the outcome in any individual case will depend heavily on its facts.
What boards need to know
Directors are expected to understand the risks facing the business and to show that they considered them. Regulators and shareholders increasingly ask for evidence, not assurances.
Good records of how decisions were made are often the best protection when things go wrong.
Preparation is the cheapest insurance any party can buy.
Placeholder quote
Practical governance steps
Company secretaries and general counsel suggest a short list of priorities for the coming quarter.
- Review board and committee terms of reference
- Update risk registers for new legal and regulatory developments
- Check that disclosures match what actually happens
- Schedule director training on emerging duties
Common questions
Does this apply everywhere? No. The rules differ between jurisdictions, and local procedure can change the practical outcome even where the principles are similar.
When should someone get advice? As early as possible. Deadlines in legal matters can be short, and early advice usually costs less than fixing problems later.
What happens next
Expect further guidance, test cases and commentary over the coming months. Criminal Minds Cast will keep following the story and update this article as the position develops.
Demo content from the Criminal Minds Cast theme. Replace or delete this article before launch.
Join the discussion